Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Papa Joe's Iacomini's. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
Chicken Livers
Always our favorite. Can't wait for fried smelt to come back.
Chicken Marsala
This meal was the best. This is the place to go for a safe, delicious night out. He had Rack of Lamb, one of his favorite.
Spaghetti or Penne
I was happy to get a 2lb container of marinara sauce from Papa Joe's take out. Absolutely incredibly delicious. Wow, what fantastic sauce. Perfect blend of tomato and spices, just lile, well even better than homemade. Keep it coming.
Eggplant Parmigiana
fabulous as usual. I love it!
Our Famous Housemade Lasagna
This is the best lasagna bar none. It's better than mom's. It's amazing. You get enough for dinner and lunch the next day. You must try this dish! Other things that are the BEST here (like you will never have better): wedding soup, sauerkraut balls, white French dressing. Come for dinner and have all of those. You're welcome.
Chicken Livers
Very tender livers lightly coated.
Chicken Parmigiana
The chicken parm is just absolutely out of this world! You get such an amazing entre for such an amazing price. I always recommend this dish to people. I mean you can't go wrong with anything on this menu. The staff is incredible. You feel like a celebrity eating here!
Another Entree or Side Dish
We attended a company Christmas party, and the food was spectacular! The beef was tender and juicy and the veggies were perfectly cooked. My husband really enjoyed the sauerkraut balls. The service was amazing and we will definitely go to Papa Joe's when we need a party venue.
Our Famous Housemade Lasagna
It was delicious I will be back!!
Filet Mignon
My filet was cooked perfect! Very tender and very flavorful. I've never had a bad meal from Papa Joe's. Their white French dressing is the best. Dine in or carry out, one of my favorite restaurants!!!
Another Entree or Side Dish
We enjoyed a lovely Valentine's Day dinner with drinks this evening! We were celebrating our 40th wedding anniversary! I originally ordered the halibut special but our server, Melanie regrettably told me that they were sold out! I then chose the lobster tail with the risotto & I wasn't disappointed!! My husband had the lasagna - his favorite dish. Our server, Melanie was friendly, attentive to detail & even took the time to take a few photos of us in front of the decorated fireplace. We always enjoy ourselves as the food & service are fabulous!
Chicken Marsala
The chicken Marsala was hands down the best I've ever had. Stuffed pepper appetizer was also amazing. Can't wait to go back.
Cashew Crusted Trout
Excellent. I have been looking for a restaurant that has great steaks for my husband and great seafood for me. This dish was outstanding. The only tough part of the evening was not trying the eggplant or chicken parm!! This restaurant is my new favorite.
Jumbo Mushroom Ravioli
This was really good!
Veal Parmigiana
The best day ever had
Chicken Francaise
Always an excellent choice, unique to Papa Joe's. Not found anywhere else. Love it!
Chicken Francaise
My husband and I have been coming to Papa Joes for years. Any dish is delicious and highly recommend the chicken franchise although penne pasta is perfect too. White french dressing is the best ever. We occasionally treat ourselves to the stuffed Hungarian peppers. The service has always been perfect too. Thank you!
Chicken Francaise
My family has been coming to Papa Joes for decades. It is the place we choose for all family occasions. We have celebrated many birthdays, graduations, and other events here. They have always been wonderful. Their menu is varied to please everyone, their prices are very fair, and the food is delicious. I order food to go from the Italian Market several times a year for gatherings at home. I think they have the best White French dressing in the area. Their drinks are generous and the happy hour have amazing deals. To top it all off, they are the nicest people you ever want to work with. I cannot say enough good things about this place. It feels like home to me....
Spinach Cannelloni
Always delicious. Goes great with salad with white french dressing & hot rolls. Sauerkraut balls excellent also.
Spaghetti or Penne
The penne was incredible. The sauce is absolutely divine and, by far, the best I have ever tasted.
Cashew Crusted Trout
Delicious with just the right amount of crusting.
Our Famous Housemade Lasagna
Cheese ravioli and lasagna were both excellent when we got them home and we live 35 minutes away. We also added salads and sauerkraut balls. There's sauerkraut balls are the best in the area!
Eggplant Parmigiana
Good
Roast Ohio Young Turkey
Just ordered Easter dinners and will post an update after we have consumed them! Love the lasagna!!!
Cashew Crusted Trout
Delicious.
8oz Char-broiled Angus Filet Mignon
Papa Joe's has THE best filet!!! You can ALWAYS expect a perfect filet - cooked to your own perfection! With a side salad with their homemade white French salad dressing - you will think you are in heaven! That dressing is so delicious I could eat it on a spoon! Honestly, I have never had a bad or even ordinary meal at Papa Joe's. Other dishes I LOVE: the meatball sandwich, spaghetti, and the cashew crusted trout - all amazing! If you want an excellent meal in a restaurant with good ambiance and friendly staff - go to Papa Joe's! Every time you will be happy!!!
Lobster Bisque
Thank you for a wonderful dinner. We enjoyed your scallops, lobster bisque, lasagna and sauerkraut balls. We visit Papa Joe's frequently and are looking forward to our next meal at your lovely restaurant.
Eggplant Parmigiana
The food and the service are always top notch at Papa Joes yet still has a warm, comfortable atmosphere.
Our Famous Lasagna
Know why they are famous for their lasagna! Every bite is delicious! A comfort must have for lunch or dinner. Bravo!
Another Entree or Side Dish
This place is a definite must for dinner! Delicious and affordable! I cant wait to go again and try something new!
Chicken Francaise
Dinner was fabulous and our server Mel was very attentive and helpful
Sicilian Nachos
Had a wonderful dinner- fish was fantastic, Brussels were fabulous and our server Mel was incredible with her recommendations!!will be back soon!!
Chicken Parmigiana
My friend who is a retired Priest in the Akron area brought us to this wonderful restaurant. Chicken Parmigiana is one of my all time favorites to order out. Never did I think this dish would be so delicious. the sauce was wonderful, chicken moist and tenders.....making my mouth water as I write this. Will be back again soon.
Spaghetti or Penne
A wonderful classic Italian dish served with marinara sauce and two hearty meatballs.
Our Famous Housemade Lasagna
we wanted to say thank you to our amazing server, melonie. she was wonderful in every way. she made each of us in our large party feel well cared for. our dinners were all delicious and served hot and quickly. you all made my husband's 60th birthday extra special and all your efforts were very appreciated! WELL DONE!
Classic Oysters Rockefeller
The appetizers and drinks are the best in town. Been to many places for "happy hour", and no place makes me happier than PAPA JOE'S. The atmosphere, customers, and staff are wonderful. And without a doubt, the bartenders make the best dirty martini's EVAH! I make a habit of stopping at Papa Joe's at least ONCE A WEEK whether it be for a quick bite (appetizer), an after-work drink, or dinner with family/friends. It's my favorite "go-to" place in town.
Cashew Crusted Trout
The trout was absolutely perfectly cooked, crunchy on the outside, just right cooked on the inside. The atmosphere is old world charm, warm and cozy. The owner Kim, is friendly and gracious and makes sure the place runs smoothly, greets dining guests and always has a smile on a warm greeting. I would recommend Papa Joe's Restaurant to anyone who wants to sample some great food and wine!
Lucca Chicken
LOVE the Lucca chicken, lasagna, bean salad, white French dressing and the brownies❤️❤️. You can't make a wrong decision from anything on their menu! Always look forward to a wonderful meal and service at Papa Joes.
Our Famous Housemade Lasagna
The BEST. Always hot & delicious. Generous with the sauce & cheese. Goes great with the dinner salad with the White French dressing & the hot dinner rolls. The sauerkraut balls for appetizer are also delicious. YUM!!!
Spinach Cannelloni
The entire meal was delicious!! My dinner started well with warm rolls and a crisp salad The main course- spinach cannelloni, was delicious!! I ate with 3 other people, who all enjoyed their meals. (2 of them raved about the lamb dishes they ate- calling the lamb the best they ever tasted!). Our server was very friendly, attentive and knowledgeable. And the Christmas decorations were festive and well-done. I highly recommend Papa Joe's!